The Best Coffee Percolator – Reviews and Buying Guide

You may not like espresso but you love percolated coffee. To you, that variety of coffee making brings out the best flavor of your favorite coffee grounds. In order to make that great coffee variety, you need a good coffee percolator on your side.

Great coffee isn’t just in the grounds or methods, it is in which coffee maker you use. When you use one of the best coffee percolators for your home, you know you are on your way to drinking great coffee.

What follows is a review of the 5 best coffee percolators on the market right now. They have what it takes to be the top of their class. When you want great coffee, you need to go with the best of the best coffee makers.

Out of the 5 best reviewed here today, we liked the WhyNotCoffee Italian Top Espresso Percolator best. Continue to read our review to find out why.

best coffee percolators

Reviews of the Best Coffee Percolator on the Market

Position

Product

Cup capacity

Water tank capacity

Editor’s rati​ng

#1

12

72 oz approx.

#2

12

72 oz approx.

#3

9

54 oz approx.

#4

8

48 oz approx

#5

6

36 oz approx.


You can get up to 12 cups of great tasting percolated coffee depending on the size of percolator you buy. Its hourglass figure will look good on your kitchen stove or other heat sources. Plus, the plastic handle keeps your hand well away from the heat.

Also, this aluminum constructed percolator is lightweight but durable and stable. Its octagon sides provide a unique brewing experience. Because it is made from aluminum this pot will not work on induction cookers.

The three easy to use parts can be disassembled and cleaned thoroughly. The plastic top should be a no-heat cap helping to protect your hand as you pour. The spout is designed to make sure there are no drips or spills.

Measuring approx. 9 x 8 x 5 inches in size, the percolator shouldn’t take up that much room in your kitchen storage or counters. A pressure release valves located in the bottom section seems to be an added feature to this unit.

One nice feature to this coffee maker is that it is made to produce good espresso style coffee. The pressure system enables you to get the full flavor out of your coffee grounds.

What We Liked

  • check
    Its unique octagon look
  • check
    The pressure percolating system
  • check
    The large capacity

What We Didn't Like

  • The plastic handle
  • The plastic knob

Hamilton Beach 40616 Review

Once you fill this percolator with coffee and water then plug it in. You can expect to wait only a few minutes before you have great tasting percolated coffee. Made from stainless steel with a chrome finish, this percolator looks good.

It is also strong. The plastic housing and handle protects your hands as well as the electric motor from damage. Its 5-1/2 x 5-1/2 x 12-3/4-inch size means you can make enough coffee for all your guests at the same time. Up to 12 cups.

The drip free spout directs the coffee into your cup and not on to your counters or table. Also, the power cord can be removed from the base to make clean up a lot easier. Another good feature is the keep warm, which automatically kicks in when brewing is done.

Then the ready to serve indicator lights up when the brewing session is over. A stainless steel permanent filter makes sure no harmful bacteria or germs reaches your coffee.  It also lasts you a long time.

A plastic stay-cool knob lets you open the pot even when it is still hot or full of hot coffee.

What We Liked

  • check
    The 12-cup capacity
  • check
    The overall design
  • check
    The removable power cord

What We Didn't Like

  • Basket lid may come loose
  • Some power cord shorting issues
  • May not make strong coffee

Coletti"Bozeman" Percolator Review

The good news is that this percolator does not contain any aluminum or plastic in its construction materials. You get the strength and good looks of stainless steel and glass. A little woo don the handle protects your hands as well as adds a touch of class to the coffee maker.

The flexibility of a good percolator coffee maker means you can use it over the stove, an induction cooker, a barbeque and even a campfire. You have lots of options at your fingertips when it comes to brewing percolated coffee.

Its overall design keeps you in control of the brewing process. Plus, with no cords to get in the way you save time and hassle. No more searching for an electrical outlet to plug it in. Just get the pot ready and place it on your heat source.

Measuring only about 8 x 5 x 7.5 inches, it is easy to pack when you travel or go camping. The outside is marked so you know how much water you have inside. Just do not overfill it or you won’t have room for your coffee.

A very simple coffee maker to use when you have time to brew some coffee.

What We Liked

  • check
    No plastic or aluminum
  • check
    Simple to use
  • check
    Nice wood handle

What We Didn't Like

  • The rounded bottom
  • Some quality control issues
  • Brass rivets tend to heat up

Farberware Classic Stainless Steel Yosemite 8-Cup Coffee Percolator

The minimum amount of coffee you can brew with this classic percolator is 4 cups. More than enough for the two of you. If you have company, you can fill it up and get 8 cups out of it.

Measuring approx. 8-1/4 x 7 x 9 inches, this stainless steel percolator is durable and strong. It also has a permanent filter basket to hold your favorite coffee. The stay-cool handle makes sure your hand does not get burnt by the heat.

When it comes time to clean the coffee maker, just disassemble it and place it in the dishwasher. This and the possible no drip spout keep the mess to clean up to a minimum. Then the tight-fitting lid makes sure the seal is very solid and closed, making sure the coffee stays inside as it percolates.

One good thing to note about this coffee maker. Its interior is designed to not absorb any odors or flavors. What you get in your cup is pure coffee only. Also, with its permanent filter, you save money by not buying the paper kind at your local store.

What We Liked

  • check
    The permanent filter
  • check
    The stay-cool handle
  • check
    Tight fitting lid

What We Didn't Like

  • Small parts can get lost
  • The top comes loose too often
  • Cup level markers difficult to read

You cannot place this coffee maker on any gas or electric stove. For that matter, you can’t use any heat source to percolate your coffee or espresso. It is electric and comes with its own power cord and stand.

With this product, you can make up to 6 cups of espresso or your favorite coffee. Its one-touch power operation makes using this coffee maker quite simple. A pressure release valve protects you from over brewing.

A thumb-controlled flip lid flips up easy when your thumb presses the button. Its handle helps protect your hand from any heat burns that may come your way. The fully automatic coffee maker just needs you to plug it in and press the start button.

The surface of the pot does get hot so be careful when handling it as you pour out your great coffee. Made from aluminum and plastic, this coffee maker does not bring a lot of weight to your coffee drinking experience.

Measuring only 120 x 190mm, his pot should not crowd any other appliance on your kitchen counter. The easy to use pot makes sure the water evenly brews your coffee.

What We Liked

  • check
    The easy to use brew operation
  • check
    The fully automatic design
  • check
    The hot pad

What We Didn't Like

  • It is small but not portable
  • The flip up lid
  • The short power cord

How To Use a Coffee Percolator

Coffee percolators may be the coffee making dinosaur of past eras. Technology has upgraded the coffee pot and re-designed them that many people may not know what a real coffee percolator does or looks like.

Here is a step by step process to help you use one of the easier to use coffee makers on the market today:

  • 1
    Make sure the percolator is clean. You may need to wash it first
  • 2
    Insert the stand and stem. Be mindful of the spring that sits about halfway up
  • 3
    Pour in the amount of water you want to turn into coffee. Just do not go past the spring
  • 4
    Place the amount of coffee you want inside the coffee basket
  • 5
    Then put the coffee basket on the already inserted stem. Don’t forget to put the lid on the coffee basket
  • 6
    After making sure the top is securely in place, put the lid on and seal the percolator
  • 7
    Place the percolator on the burner (or just plug in the electric one)
  • 8
    Be patient and wait while the percolating process does its stuff
  • 9
    When the process is complete you can let it sit for a bit till any sediments sink down to the bottom

How to Make Coffee in a Percolator

According to some coffee fanatics, percolating your coffee is not the best way to make coffee. It is considered to be one of the worst ways to brew coffee. That is because the water has to boil before it percolates.

Coffee Percolator Reviews

This makes the water too hot and extracts too much coffee flavor from your grounds. The end product could be too acidity and a little bit bitter to the taste. But then you may like your coffee that way, so it is only the worst way to those who don’t like that kind of strong coffee.

How to make coffee in a percolator follows the same steps as above but has a few extra steps not included in those instructions. Here are those steps:

  • Open your percolator and take out the coffee basket. You can leave the stem inside if you want.
  • Grind your own coffee beans or open up your favorite package of pre-ground coffee
  • Fill the basket with as much or as little coffee as you want. Some people say 1 tbsp. per cup but put the amount of coffee according to your tastes.
  • Check Square
    Some people say that you should use filtered water, but it makes no real difference. Use the water you like
  • Check Square
    Place the percolator on the stove or heat source. Or plug it in.  Some people think you should turn the heat down at the first perc, but it is not a hard and fast rule.
  • Check Square
    You may want to remove the percolator the moment it stops percolating but you have better things to do than watch a pot boil. Remove it when you are ready to serve
  • Check Square
    When it is ready to serve, remove the stem and coffee basket. If you don’t you may get super strong-tasting coffee.
  • Check Square
    When you open the lid, to remove the inner parts, be careful not to burn yourselves.
  • Check Square
    Serve your percolated coffee

What We Found

As we wrote this review we found that the topic brought back childhood memories. We remember these old percolators and are surprised that technology has not upgraded the system.

The models you see in this review and on same at your supermarket are designed the exact same way when our grandparents were young. It is not a bad thing, it is just surprising that technology hasn’t been able to improve on a good system.

Also, there are still only two ways to make percolated coffee. You can use the electric plug in models or the very old-fashioned place on the heat source and wait method.

With the invention of the induction cooking system, you have to make sure your old-fashioned percolator will trigger the magnet sensors, so the induction cooker can brew your coffee.

However, you do it is up to your preference. Just don’t listen to those naysayers who think this method is the worst method. Your preferences are not that bad.

Final Words

Brewing coffee to some is an art form. They want their coffee to be just right. They go to great lengths to grind their coffee after searching long and hard for the right beans to use. Then they go to even greater lengths trying to find that perfect up-to-date coffee maker.

They miss out on the old ways and fine tasting coffee by doing that. The percolating method may be old-fashioned and impossible to upgrade but it is still an easy way to make coffee.

These 5 competitors in our round-up prove that. Now for the winner of this round-up. As usual, our competitors brought their ‘A’ game and did not disappoint. But we picked the WhyNotCoffee Italian Top Espresso Percolator as the winner.

Its large capacities and flexibility made it stand out above the rest. Your choice may be a bit different but that is okay. For our coffee drinking contest, we felt that the model outshone the others.

Leave a Comment

WhyNotCoffee.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, and we get a commission on purchases made through our links.